DIY Antique Elm Stool

You’ve probably seen them in your Instagram feed, Pinterest and in the pages of magazines: antique elm wood stools. They come in the form of tables and benches as well, as you can see here in Michelle Janeen‘s living room:

They’re the perfect mix of simple, rustic and chic, and I’ve been wanting to get my hands on one. The only problem? The price tag is usually in the hundreds, and they’re in limited supply since these are antiques and not mass produced.

I knew there had to be a way to recreate the look on a budget, and set out to find the most inexpensive stool to start with. Amazon to the rescue!

At only $35, it was a no-brainer. I bought the 18″ size, which is perfect for a small side table in our living room (update: they just raised the price yesterday after a bunch of you bought them up, but it’s still a great deal!)  Here it is next to our sofa:

It looks out of place in this photo because it clashes with the deeper wood tone and rustic style of our coffee table.

The goal was to make the smooth, new wood look authentically aged and rustic, and stain it to match the tone of the coffee table. I’ve done my fair share of rustic wood DIY’s in the past, but this time I decided to introduce a couple new tools to my arsenal.

  1. Orbital Sander – one of my most used and loved tools. A Mouse sander works just as well (in fact it’s easier to get into tight spaces) but the orbital is a bit faster.
  2. Planer – this tool shaves down wood with a spinning blade and is super useful for many woodworking projects. If you don’t own one and don’t want to get one, try using a hand planer or wood rasp (it will just take a lot longer!)
  3. Jigsaw – a basic DIYer’s essential, this tool has a reciprocating blade that makes quick straight cuts.
  4. Drill with wire brush attachment These coarse wire brushes are designed for heavy duty surface removal (rust, layers of paint, etc). This set on Amazon is a great deal!

There are many different ways to go about making new wood look old, and I’ve tried a lot of them, but the combination of the above tools have produced the best results in the shortest amount of time. I always recommend experimenting with your technique and seeing what you like! There is no one “right” approach.

I tested each tool on a piece of scrap wood first to get the hang of things, and I’d highly advise you to do the same. To begin, I grabbed the tool that does the most damage—the planer.

I started by planing down the edges in random spots, then did the same along the flat surfaces. The goal is to make the wood look worn and uneven by getting rid of the straight, smooth lines.

Don’t be afraid to take a few bigger chunks out, too! It can look pretty extreme but the sander will smooth it all out. The planer is a powerful tool and can take a little while to get comfortable with it, so make sure to get some practice runs in first.

Once the wood was sufficiently mangled, it was time for the next step: the jigsaw.

This is where you’ll recreate the look of saw marks, etching grooves and lines as you run the jigsaw back and forth along the wood. I shared a couple videos of this process in my Instagram stories (definitely give those a watch if you plan on doing this project!)

You’ll want to spend some extra time on the edges, cutting deeper grooves to make it look like raw wood edges.

Make sure to carry the grooves over along the top, and cut some at an angle.

Keep going until you’ve covered each surface and are happy with the level of distressing.

Alright, the heavy duty stuff is over!

Now it’s time to sand everything down. Real aged wood that has been around for decades is smooth as it has been worn down over time. We don’t want any visible fresh cuts or rough edges.

An orbital sander makes fast work of this, but you’ll find that if you sand too much, you’ll start to erase some of the jigsaw marks. You can either sand those areas a little less or go back and make deeper grooves with the jigsaw. This is the fastest step and shouldn’t take longer than 15-20 min or so.

Finally, we have the last and most important step. The secret ingredient to getting that real aged look—a wire brush:

This was actually my first time using wire brush attachments on my drill, and I found a great deal on this set on Amazon:

I played around with a couple different attachments, but the largest disc was my favorite so I stuck with that. The coarse wire cuts deep, tiny grooves into the wood, opening up the grain.

This is the texture you’ll find on old wood that has been worn away by the elements and fluctuating conditions over time. I was pretty blown away with the results and wondered how I’d never thought to try this sooner…

After running the brush along the wood going with the grain, I held it perpendicular to the wood and went against the grain in random areas. This step definitely takes the longest, but it makes the biggest difference (and it’s pretty fun!). I also went over any areas that the sander missed where the cut marks were too clean.

This step took me a couple hours, but you can do less or more to your preference. Finally, it’s ready to stain!

I grabbed a couple stains from my garage that I thought could be a good match, and did a quick test. Here I’m using two of my favorites, Minwax Weathered Oak and Special Walnut.

I assumed since the wood was so light that it would play nicely with the stains, but it applied much warmer.

Special Walnut would have been way too brown, so I went with Weathered Oak and brushed on a light coat.

This proves you can never trust the color in the can! Your wood is what determines the color output.

I looked in the garage again and found a can of Driftwood, which is slightly grayer than Weathered Oak.

After the first coat was dry, I gave the stool a second coat of Driftwood. And it looked pretty good!

If I had to do it all over again, I’d skip the Weathered Oak stain and only use Driftwood.

Time for the real test… a side by side next to our coffee table.

Not an exact match, but I wasn’t done yet. I found a can of black wax and figured I’d give it a shot (I’m using Maison Blanche chalk wax, but any black or dark wax will do).

You simply rub it on the wood with a cloth and it settles into the grooves, making the texture more defined. The wax also darkened and neutralized the wood tone a little. I’d say the color is pretty close!

You’ll want to protect your finish by sealing it with a varnish. I gave mine a few coats of this matte polyurethane, which is water based for easy cleanup and dries invisible.

Now this side table fits right in with the coffee table!

Haven’t decided if I’ll keep it next to the chair or over by the couch yet…

I considered getting two, but we haven’t had a need for the extra table space yet. I can always make another one!

What do you think? Pretty convincing as an antique, right?

I love it when DIYs work out so well, especially when anyone can do it in 1 day on a budget!

Save this one to your Pinterest board for later, and make sure to go back and watch my Instagram stories to see videos of the process.

Next up, we’re keeping the DIY train going with a custom built hanging bed at The Riverside Retreat. You’ll definitely want to tune in for this one!

23 thoughts on “DIY Antique Elm Stool

  1. Love LOVE LOVE THIS! By the time I went to buy this stool, it was gone, so I bought a used one that was 29.00 and it came in one day, and is PERFECT! I didn’t care if it was used or not, since I’m going to make it looked used…but it looks brand new! I will share a pic when I’m done! Thanks Jenna Sue! I have had my eye on these stools for so long, and it never occurred to me, to diy it! You’re genius!!! Anyways… can’t wait.
    to Get started😉

  2. You are simply AMAZING!! You never cease to amaze me with your DIY skills!! I have learned so much from you!! I read 28 DIY blogs and hands down you stand out to me every time!! Well Done Jenna!!

  3. Love the look- you did a great job on the stool and your instructions. Did you have any problem with the polyurethane adhering on top of the black wax?
    Thanks for sharing!

  4. You are such an artist!!! My all time favorite poly is Vermont Natural Coatings. It’s super green, food safe, no VOCs and works great!

  5. Do you think the aging techniques would work on a front door? Our dogs have scratched it up, and I was planning on sanding it down and restraining, but I love the weathered look!

    1. I would be a little nervous about opening up the grain when it’s exposed to the elements. Honestly if you’re going for that look, I’d try to find a real antique door somewhere!

  6. Jenna Sue, amazing job on the stool! Love how it looks with the “coffee table.” I’m looking for a similar coffee table. Any suggestions?

  7. What color and fabric is your Sixpenny chairs? Also, are they more of a beige grey or purple grey? I cannot tell by the pictures. Thank you in advance.

  8. Best DIY yet!!! I especially liked the comment about wishing you had tried the driftwood stain first. I always hit the “undo” button in those scenarios only to remember there is no such button in home improvement. 😂 Still looks amazing though!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *